Monument, Colo. – November 16, 2026 – [KOREWIRE] — El Paso County and Buc-ee’s have filed motions to dismiss a lawsuit challenging the El Paso County Board of County Commissioners’ Aug. 27 decision to classify a proposed Buc-ee’s travel center on the Palmer Divide as an allowable use under the county’s C-1 commercial zoning designation.

The lawsuit, filed Sept. 24 under Colorado Rule of Civil Procedure 106(a)(4), challenges the commissioners’ 4-1 decision allowing the proposed development near County Line Road in northern El Paso County to proceed through the county’s administrative development review process.

The plaintiffs include Tri-Lakes Preservation Inc. (TPI), The Community Voice, several area residents and a homeowners association. They contend that the commissioners improperly interpreted and applied the county’s Land Development Code when determining that the proposed travel center qualified as a permitted use.

The Aug. 27 decision followed a public hearing at which more than 160 citizens participated, with the overwhelming majority speaking in opposition to the proposed development.

The commissioners’ decision addressed the land-use classification. It did not approve the site’s development plan or authorize construction.

Defendants file motions to dismiss
El Paso County and Buc-ee’s are asking the court to dismiss the lawsuit based on two principal arguments.

Legal standing: According to a legal update provided by TPI, El Paso County and Buc-ee’s contend that the plaintiffs lack standing to challenge the commissioners’ decision because the ruling determined only whether the proposed development qualified as an allowable use under C-1 zoning. The defendants argue that potential impacts on neighboring property owners are too indirect at this stage because the site development plan has not been approved.

Land Development Code interpretation: According to the same TPI update, the defendants maintain that the commissioners correctly interpreted the county’s Land Development Code and had the authority to determine that the proposed travel center qualified as a permitted use. The defendants dispute the plaintiffs’ interpretation of the code, including whether the proposed development must be compared with a specific permitted use, whether its size is relevant to C-1 zoning and whether it must primarily serve the surrounding neighborhood.

The defendants also argue that the plaintiffs’ claims can be resolved based on the language of the code without a full review of the administrative record.

The motions present the defendants’ legal arguments. The court has not ruled on those arguments.

Plaintiffs file responses opposing dismissal
Responses opposing both motions to dismiss have been filed with the El Paso County District Court, according to attorney Michael T. Rose, counsel for several plaintiffs. Attorneys from Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck LLP and community legal counsel represent the plaintiffs in the case.

The plaintiffs maintain that they have legal standing to challenge the commissioners’ decision and that the county’s interpretation of its Land Development Code warrants judicial review.

They contend that the commissioners exceeded their authority or misapplied the code in determining that the proposed Buc-ee’s development qualifies as an allowable use under C-1 zoning.

The plaintiffs are asking the court to allow the lawsuit to proceed so the zoning determination can be evaluated against the full administrative record.

Court to determine next steps
The court will consider the parties’ arguments and determine whether the motions to dismiss should be granted or denied.
If the motions are denied, the case may proceed to additional briefing and judicial review of the administrative record. That review would address whether the commissioners exceeded their jurisdiction or abused their discretion in making the zoning determination.

According to information provided by TPI, a substantive ruling on the motions to dismiss is not expected before the end of 2026 at the earliest.

No final judicial determination has been made on the underlying zoning dispute.

Community information and development review
The Community Voice, a nonprofit organization serving northern El Paso County, has been providing residents with information about the proposed Buc-ee’s development, the county’s review process and the related legal proceedings.

“Responses to both motions to dismiss have now been filed, and the court will determine whether the case moves forward,” said Ron Scott, chairman of The Community Voice. “We will continue sharing information from Tri-Lakes Preservation and other available sources so residents can follow the proceedings and understand the status of the proposed development.”

Separate from the lawsuit, the proposed Buc-ee’s development remains subject to applicable county development review requirements.

The Community Voice will continue providing updates as additional court decisions and county development information become available.
For additional information, visit https://www.thecommunityvoicecolorado.com.

Case and land-use reference information
Court: El Paso County District Court, Colorado
Legal action: C.R.C.P. 106(a)(4) Complaint for Judicial Review
Plaintiffs: Tri-Lakes Preservation Inc., The Community Voice and other named plaintiffs
Defendants: El Paso County Board of County Commissioners and Buc-ee’s EPCO LLC
Complaint date: Sept. 24, 2026
County land-use appeal: APP261
County resolution: No. 26-260
Court case number: 2026CV032336

The county appeal and resolution numbers identify the land-use decision being challenged and are separate from the court case number.

About The Community Voice

The Community Voice is a Colorado nonprofit organization that provides information to residents and business owners in northern El Paso County about local government decisions, proposed developments, and other matters affecting the community.
Informed. Engaged. United.

Media Contact Details

The Community Voice
mediathecommunityvoice@gmail.com
https://www.thecommunityvoicecolorado.com

News Source: PinionNewswire 

About The Author